Formulating Statistical Questions
Lesson: Formulating Statistical Questions
In statistics, we often ask questions so we can collect data and learn something from it. But not every question is a statistical question.
A statistical question is a question that expects different answers from different people, objects, or times. It is answered by collecting data that can vary.
A non-statistical question has one exact answer, or it does not expect much variation. These questions do not need a set of different data values to answer them.
Learning the difference is important because statistics is about studying variability. Variability means that the data values are not all the same.
1. What makes a question statistical?
A question is statistical if it does both of these things:
- It can be answered by collecting data.
- It expects the data to have variation, meaning the answers will not all be identical.
For example, think about the question: "How many minutes do 6th grade students spend reading each night?"
This is a statistical question because if you ask many 6th grade students, their answers will probably be different. Some may read for 10 minutes, some for 20 minutes, and some for 30 minutes or more.
2. What makes a question non-statistical?
A non-statistical question usually asks for one exact fact.
For example: "How many days are in one week?"
This is not a statistical question because the answer is always 7. There is no variability.
Another example is: "What is the height of the classroom door?"
If you mean one specific door, then the question has one measurement answer. It does not ask for a group of data values that vary.
3. A helpful way to decide
When you read a question, ask yourself:
- Am I collecting data from a group, or am I just finding one fact?
- Do I expect the answers to be different?
If the answers are expected to vary, then the question is likely statistical.
If there is only one exact answer, then it is not statistical.
4. Look for words that suggest variability
Statistical questions often include words or ideas like these:
- students, people, cars, pets
- how many, how much, how long
- in our class, in the school, during the week
These clues often show that you are asking about a group, and groups usually have different values.
But be careful: just because a question says how many does not automatically make it statistical.
For example, "How many months are in a year?" is still not statistical, because the answer is always 12.
5. Changing a non-statistical question into a statistical question
Sometimes a question is close to being statistical, but it needs to be rewritten.
Here is a non-statistical question: "What is my shoe size?"
This has one answer for one person. It is not statistical.
Now change it to: "What are the shoe sizes of students in our class?"
Now it is statistical because different students will likely have different shoe sizes.
Here is another example:
- Non-statistical: "How old is the principal?"
- Statistical: "How old are the teachers at our school?"
The second question expects a range of ages, not one exact answer.
6. Worked Examples
Example 1: Is this a statistical question?
Question: "How many letters are in the word 'triangle'?"
Step 1: Does it ask for data from a group? No.
Step 2: Will the answer vary? No.
Answer: This is not a statistical question.
There is one exact answer: the word triangle has 8 letters.
We can write that as $$8$$ letters.
Example 2: Is this a statistical question?
Question: "How many siblings do students in our class have?"
Step 1: Does it ask for data from a group? Yes, it asks about students in the class.
Step 2: Will the answers vary? Yes. Some students may have 0 siblings, some may have 1, 2, or more.
Answer: This is a statistical question.
A possible set of answers might be:
$$0,\ 1,\ 2,\ 2,\ 3,\ 1,\ 4$$
These values show variability because they are not all the same.
Example 3: Rewrite the question
Original question: "What is the temperature outside right now?"
This is not a statistical question because it asks for one measurement at one time.
To make it statistical, we need a question that expects different data values.
Improved question: "What are the outdoor temperatures at noon during the next 10 days?"
Now the answers can vary from day to day, so it is a statistical question.
A possible data set could be:
$$72,\ 74,\ 71,\ 69,\ 73,\ 75,\ 70,\ 68,\ 72,\ 74$$
Example 4: Compare two questions
Question A: "How tall is Maria?"
Question B: "How tall are the girls in Maria's basketball team?"
Question A is non-statistical because it asks about one person and expects one measurement.
Question B is statistical because it asks about a group, and the heights will likely vary.
So only Question B is a statistical question.
7. Common mistakes to avoid
- Mistake 1: Thinking every question with numbers is statistical. A question can include numbers and still have only one exact answer.
- Mistake 2: Thinking every question about a group is statistical. If all answers are guaranteed to be the same, then it is not statistical.
- Mistake 3: Forgetting about variability. Variability is the key idea in statistical questions.
8. Practice thinking
Decide whether each question is statistical or non-statistical:
- "How many books does each student in our class have at home?"
- "How many wheels does a bicycle have?"
- "How long does it take students in our class to get to school?"
- "What is the name of our school?"
Answers:
- Statistical — book counts will vary.
- Non-statistical — a bicycle has one exact number of wheels, which is 2.
- Statistical — travel times will vary.
- Non-statistical — there is one exact school name.
9. Summary
A statistical question is a question that expects variation in the answers. It is answered by collecting data from a group or over time.
A non-statistical question has one exact answer and does not expect variability.
To tell the difference, ask yourself: "Will the answers vary?" If yes, the question is probably statistical.
Put what you read to the test
You've worked through Formulating Statistical Questions. Try answering a few questions to see what stuck — and what might deserve a quick reread before you move on.