Statistical Questions and Data Collection
Statistical Questions and Data Collection
In math, we sometimes ask questions so we can learn about a group. To answer these questions, we collect data. Data is information, such as numbers, choices, or counts.
But not every question is a statistical question. A statistical question is a question that expects different answers from different people or objects in a group.
For example, if you ask, “How many letters are in the word cat?” there is only one answer: 3. That is not a statistical question.
If you ask, “How many letters are in each student’s first name in our class?” the answers will probably be different. Some students may have 3 letters, some 5, and some 7. That is a statistical question.
When we ask a statistical question, we usually need to collect data from a group. Then we can study the answers to look for patterns, compare results, and understand what is typical.
What makes a question statistical?
- It is about a group, not just one person or one thing.
- It expects variation, which means the answers can be different.
- It can be answered by collecting data.
Examples of statistical questions:
- How many books did students in our class read last month?
- What is the favorite fruit of students in 5th grade?
- How many minutes do students at our school spend reading each night?
Examples of non-statistical questions:
- How old is Maria?
- What is the color of our classroom door?
- How many days are in a week?
These are not statistical questions because they ask for one answer, not a set of different answers.
Understanding variation
Variation means the data values are not all the same. In real life, people and objects are often different in some way.
For example, if you ask, “How tall are the students in our class?” you should expect different heights. That difference is variation.
Variation is important because it helps us know that a question is statistical. If all answers must be the same, then the question is not statistical.
Collecting data
After writing a statistical question, the next step is to collect data carefully. Good data collection helps us get useful answers.
There are different ways to collect data:
- Survey: asking people questions and recording their answers.
- Count: finding how many of each kind there are.
- Measure: finding length, height, time, or weight.
- Observe: watching and recording what happens.
Steps for collecting data
- Write a clear statistical question.
- Decide who or what you will collect data from.
- Choose a fair way to gather the data.
- Record the data carefully.
- Check that your data matches the question.
Who should you ask?
The group you want to learn about is called a population. For example, if you want to know about all 5th grade students in your school, then all 5th grade students are the population.
Sometimes it is hard to ask everyone in a population. Instead, we ask a smaller group called a sample.
A sample should represent the larger group fairly. That means it should not include only one type of student if the whole group is more mixed.
Random sampling
One fair way to choose a sample is random sampling. Random means every person in the group has an equal chance of being chosen.
For example, if there are 100 students in 5th grade, you could put all 100 names in a box and draw 20 names without looking. That is a random sample.
Random sampling helps make the data more fair because you are not just choosing your friends or the students sitting nearest to you.
Why fair data matters
If you only survey one small part of a group, your results may not match the whole group.
For example, suppose you ask, “What is the favorite school lunch of 5th graders?” If you only ask students in one classroom, your answers may not represent all 5th graders.
If you ask students from several classes using random sampling, your data will likely be more useful.
Writing good survey questions
A good survey question should be clear and easy to understand. It should match exactly what you want to learn.
Here are some tips:
- Use simple words.
- Ask only one thing at a time.
- Do not make the question confusing.
- Make sure the answers can vary.
For example, “What is your favorite recess game?” is a clear question. But “Do you like fun games at recess and lunch?” is harder to answer because it asks about more than one time.
Worked Example 1: Is it statistical?
Question: “How many siblings does each student in our class have?”
Step 1: Is it about a group? Yes, it is about students in our class.
Step 2: Will the answers vary? Yes. Some students may have 0 siblings, some 1, some 2, and some more.
Step 3: Can data be collected? Yes, we can ask each student and record the answers.
Answer: This is a statistical question.
Now look at this question: “How many siblings does Ava have?”
This asks about one person and expects one answer. It is not a statistical question.
Worked Example 2: Choosing a good sample
Question: “What is the favorite sport of 5th graders at our school?”
You want to learn about all 5th graders, so the population is all 5th grade students at the school.
Suppose there are 90 students in 5th grade. Asking all 90 students would be best, but if that is not possible, you can use a sample.
A fair sample might be 18 students chosen randomly.
One way to do this:
- Write each student’s name on a slip of paper.
- Put all 90 slips in a container.
- Mix them well.
- Draw 18 names without looking.
This is better than asking only your friends, because your friends may like the same sports you do.
Worked Example 3: Collecting and recording data
Question: “How many minutes do students in our class read at home each night?”
This is a statistical question because the answers will probably vary.
Suppose you survey 8 students and get these answers in minutes:
$$15,\ 20,\ 30,\ 20,\ 10,\ 25,\ 30,\ 15$$
This list is your data. Each number is one data value.
You can organize the data in a table:
- 10 minutes: 1 student
- 15 minutes: 2 students
- 20 minutes: 2 students
- 25 minutes: 1 student
- 30 minutes: 2 students
Notice the data has variation. The reading time is not the same for everyone.
Worked Example 4: Fixing a weak question
Weak question: “Do you like school?”
This question may be too general. Different students might think about different parts of school, such as math, lunch, or recess.
A better question is: “What is your favorite subject in school?”
This new question is clearer. It is also statistical because different students may choose different subjects.
Another better question could be: “How many minutes of homework do 5th grade students have on a typical school night?”
This question is also statistical because the answers can vary.
Common mistakes to watch for
- Asking about only one person: That usually makes it non-statistical.
- Writing a question with only one answer: If there is no variation, it is not statistical.
- Choosing an unfair sample: Asking only one small group can give biased results.
- Recording data carelessly: Missing or mixed-up answers can lead to mistakes.
How to check your own work
When you write a question, ask yourself:
- Am I asking about a group?
- Will the answers probably be different?
- Can I collect data to answer it?
When you collect data, ask yourself:
- Did I choose people fairly?
- Did I record each answer correctly?
- Does my data match the question I asked?
Summary
A statistical question is a question about a group that expects different answers. Those differences are called variation.
To answer a statistical question, we collect data by surveying, counting, measuring, or observing. If we cannot ask everyone, we can use a sample.
A random sample is a fair way to choose people because everyone has the same chance of being selected. Good questions and fair data collection help us learn true information about a group.
Put what you read to the test
You've worked through Statistical Questions and Data Collection. Try answering a few questions to see what stuck — and what might deserve a quick reread before you move on.