Defining vs. Non-Defining Attributes
Defining vs. Non-Defining Attributes
When we look at shapes, we can notice many things about them. We might see their color, their size, or which way they are turned. We might also notice how many sides they have or whether they have corners.
In math, some shape attributes are defining attributes. These are the special parts that make a shape the shape it is. Other attributes are non-defining attributes. These are things that can change without changing the shape's name.
This lesson will help you learn how to tell the difference.
What is an attribute?
An attribute is a feature or part of something. Shapes have attributes too.
- A shape may have sides.
- A shape may have corners.
- A shape may be large or small.
- A shape may be blue, red, or green.
Not all of these attributes are equally important in math.
Defining attributes
Defining attributes are the features that tell us what a shape really is. If a defining attribute changes, the shape may become a different shape.
For 2D shapes, defining attributes often include:
- the number of sides
- the number of corners
- whether sides are straight
- whether some sides are the same length
- whether the shape has certain kinds of angles
For example:
- A triangle has 3 sides and 3 corners.
- A rectangle has 4 sides and 4 square corners.
- A hexagon has 6 sides.
These are rules for the shape. That is why they are called defining attributes.
Non-defining attributes
Non-defining attributes are features that do not decide the shape's name. These things can change, but the shape stays the same kind of shape.
Non-defining attributes often include:
- color
- size
- direction or orientation (which way the shape is turned)
- where the shape is placed on the page
For example, a triangle can be:
- small or large
- red or yellow
- pointing up, down, or sideways
It is still a triangle as long as it keeps its defining attributes: 3 sides and 3 corners.
A shape does not change its name just because it turns
Sometimes students think a shape is different when it is turned. But turning a shape does not change the kind of shape it is.
If you turn a square, it is still a square. If you turn a triangle, it is still a triangle.
The defining attributes stay the same even when the shape looks different on the page.
Think: "What must be true?"
To decide whether an attribute is defining, ask this question:
Does this feature have to be true for the shape to have this name?
If the answer is yes, it is probably a defining attribute.
If the answer is no, it is probably a non-defining attribute.
Look at these examples:
- A triangle must have 3 sides. That is defining.
- A triangle does not have to be green. That is non-defining.
- A rectangle must have 4 square corners. That is defining.
- A rectangle does not have to be big. That is non-defining.
Worked Example 1: Finding the defining attribute
A shape is blue. It has 3 sides. Which attribute tells us it is a triangle?
Step 1: Look at the attributes.
- blue
- 3 sides
Step 2: Ask which one decides the shape's name.
Color does not decide the name. A triangle can be any color.
But a triangle must have 3 sides.
Answer: 3 sides is the defining attribute. Blue is a non-defining attribute.
Worked Example 2: Same shape, different look
Look at two shapes:
- Shape A is a small square.
- Shape B is a large square turned like a diamond.
Are they both squares?
Step 1: Ignore size and direction. Those may be non-defining.
Step 2: Check the defining attributes of a square.
- 4 equal sides
- 4 square corners
If both shapes have these attributes, then both are squares.
Answer: Yes. They are both squares. The size and the way the shape is turned do not change its name.
Worked Example 3: Sorting attributes
A rectangle has these attributes:
- 4 sides
- red
- 4 square corners
- large
Which are defining attributes, and which are non-defining?
Step 1: Think about what a rectangle must have.
- It must have 4 sides.
- It must have 4 square corners.
Step 2: Think about what can change.
- It can be red, blue, or any color.
- It can be large or small.
Answer:
- Defining: 4 sides, 4 square corners
- Non-defining: red, large
Worked Example 4: Is it still the same polygon?
A shape has 6 sides. One is small, one is medium, and one is large, but all have 6 sides. Are they all hexagons?
Step 1: Remember the defining attribute of a hexagon.
A hexagon has 6 sides.
Step 2: Check the other feature.
The shapes are different sizes. Size is a non-defining attribute.
Answer: Yes. They are all hexagons because they all have 6 sides.
How this helps you classify shapes
To classify shapes means to sort them into groups. In math, we group shapes by defining attributes, not by non-defining ones.
For example, if you are sorting shapes, you should group together:
- all shapes with 3 sides as triangles
- all shapes with 4 sides and 4 square corners as rectangles
- all shapes with 6 sides as hexagons
You should not sort them only by:
- color
- size
- whether they are turned
Helpful reminders
- Count sides and corners.
- Look for angle clues, like square corners.
- Ignore color.
- Ignore size.
- Ignore which way the shape points.
Quick check
Decide whether each attribute is defining or non-defining.
- A triangle is yellow.
Yellow is non-defining. - A shape has 4 square corners.
4 square corners is defining for rectangles and squares. - A hexagon is tiny.
Tiny is non-defining. - A polygon has 5 sides.
5 sides is defining for a pentagon.
Summary
Shapes have many attributes, but only some are used to name and classify them. Defining attributes are the important math rules, like number of sides, corners, and certain angles. Non-defining attributes are things like color, size, and direction.
When you study a shape, ask yourself: What must be true about this shape? That will help you find the defining attributes and choose the correct shape name.
Put what you read to the test
You've worked through Defining vs. Non-Defining Attributes. Try answering a few questions to see what stuck — and what might deserve a quick reread before you move on.