The Law of Sines and the Ambiguous Case
Lesson: The Law of Sines and the Ambiguous Case
In trigonometry, we often solve right triangles using sine, cosine, and tangent. But many real problems involve oblique triangles, which are triangles that do not have a right angle.
To solve oblique triangles, one of the main tools we use is the Law of Sines. This law connects side lengths and the angles opposite them. It is especially useful when we know:
- two angles and one side, or
- two sides and a non-included angle.
The second case can lead to something called the ambiguous case. In that situation, there may be zero, one, or two possible triangles. This lesson will show you how to recognize each possibility and solve correctly.
1. Naming sides and angles
In any triangle, sides are named opposite their matching angles:
- side \(a\) is opposite angle \(A\)
- side \(b\) is opposite angle \(B\)
- side \(c\) is opposite angle \(C\)
This matching is very important when using the Law of Sines. Always pair each side with its opposite angle.
2. The Law of Sines
The Law of Sines states:
$$ \frac{a}{\sin A}=\frac{b}{\sin B}=\frac{c}{\sin C} $$It can also be written as:
$$ \frac{\sin A}{a}=\frac{\sin B}{b}=\frac{\sin C}{c} $$You may use whichever form is more convenient. The key idea is that each side must be matched with its opposite angle.
3. When to use the Law of Sines
The Law of Sines is usually the best method when you know:
- AAS: two angles and one side
- ASA: two angles and the included side
- SSA: two sides and a non-included angle
The first two cases give a unique triangle. The third case, SSA, is the one that may be ambiguous.
4. Solving triangles with AAS or ASA
If you know two angles, first find the third angle using the triangle angle sum:
$$ A+B+C=180^\circ $$Then use the Law of Sines to find the missing sides.
Worked Example 1: A unique triangle
Suppose \(A=40^\circ\), \(B=65^\circ\), and \(a=12\). Find the remaining angle and sides.
Step 1: Find the third angle.
$$ C=180^\circ-40^\circ-65^\circ=75^\circ $$Step 2: Use the Law of Sines to find \(b\).
$$ \frac{a}{\sin A}=\frac{b}{\sin B} $$ $$ \frac{12}{\sin 40^\circ}=\frac{b}{\sin 65^\circ} $$ $$ b=12\cdot\frac{\sin 65^\circ}{\sin 40^\circ} $$ $$ b\approx 12\cdot\frac{0.9063}{0.6428}\approx 16.92 $$Step 3: Find \(c\).
$$ \frac{12}{\sin 40^\circ}=\frac{c}{\sin 75^\circ} $$ $$ c=12\cdot\frac{\sin 75^\circ}{\sin 40^\circ} $$ $$ c\approx 12\cdot\frac{0.9659}{0.6428}\approx 18.03 $$Answer: \(C=75^\circ\), \(b\approx 16.92\), and \(c\approx 18.03\).
5. The ambiguous case: SSA
The ambiguous case happens when we know:
- an angle, say \(A\)
- its opposite side, say \(a\)
- another side, say \(b\)
So we know \(A\), \(a\), and \(b\). This is called SSA because we know two sides and an angle that is not between them.
This situation is called ambiguous because the side of length \(b\) may be able to form:
- no triangle,
- one triangle, or
- two different triangles.
Why can there be two triangles?
When you use the Law of Sines to find an angle, you often get a value for a sine, such as \(\sin B=0.6\). Since sine has the same value for two angles between \(0^\circ\) and \(180^\circ\), both of these are possible:
$$ B=\sin^{-1}(0.6)=36.87^\circ $$and
$$ B=180^\circ-36.87^\circ=143.13^\circ $$That is the source of the ambiguity. However, both angles are only valid if the triangle angle sum still works.
6. A helpful height idea
Suppose \(A\) is acute and we know \(a\), \(b\), and angle \(A\). A useful comparison is the height:
$$ h=b\sin A $$Then the number of possible triangles can be determined by comparing \(a\) with \(h\) and \(b\).
When \(A\) is acute:
- If \(a<h\), there is no triangle.
- If \(a=h\), there is one triangle and it is a right triangle.
- If \(h<a<b\), there are two triangles.
- If \(a\ge b\), there is one triangle.
This is a very useful shortcut for SSA when the given angle is acute.
7. Solving the ambiguous case using the Law of Sines
In SSA problems, a common first step is:
$$ \frac{a}{\sin A}=\frac{b}{\sin B} $$Solve for \(\sin B\):
$$ \sin B=\frac{b\sin A}{a} $$Then check:
- If \(\sin B>1\), no triangle exists.
- If \(\sin B=1\), one triangle exists.
- If \(0<\sin B<1\), one or two triangles may exist.
After finding one angle \(B\), also test the second possible angle:
$$ B_2=180^\circ-B_1 $$If \(A+B_2<180^\circ\), then the second triangle is valid. If not, only one triangle exists.
Worked Example 2: No triangle
Given \(A=35^\circ\), \(a=4\), and \(b=8\), determine how many triangles are possible.
Method 1: Use the height.
$$ h=b\sin A=8\sin 35^\circ $$ $$ h\approx 8(0.5736)=4.59 $$Since \(a=4\) and \(4<4.59\), we have \(a<h\). Therefore, no triangle is possible.
Method 2: Use the Law of Sines.
$$ \sin B=\frac{b\sin A}{a}=\frac{8\sin 35^\circ}{4} $$ $$ \sin B\approx \frac{8(0.5736)}{4}=1.1472 $$Since sine cannot be greater than 1, this confirms that no triangle exists.
Worked Example 3: Two possible triangles
Given \(A=30^\circ\), \(a=7\), and \(b=10\), solve the triangle(s).
Step 1: Check whether ambiguity is possible.
$$ h=b\sin A=10\sin 30^\circ=10(0.5)=5 $$We compare \(a=7\) with \(h=5\) and \(b=10\):
$$ 5<7<10 $$Since \(h<a<b\), there are two triangles.
Step 2: Find angle \(B\).
$$ \sin B=\frac{b\sin A}{a}=\frac{10\sin 30^\circ}{7}=rac{10(0.5)}{7}=\frac{5}{7} $$ $$ \sin B\approx 0.7143 $$First possible angle:
$$ B_1=\sin^{-1}(0.7143)\approx 45.58^\circ $$Second possible angle:
$$ B_2=180^\circ-45.58^\circ=134.42^\circ $$Step 3: Find angle \(C\) for each triangle.
Triangle 1:
$$ C_1=180^\circ-30^\circ-45.58^\circ=104.42^\circ $$Triangle 2:
$$ C_2=180^\circ-30^\circ-134.42^\circ=15.58^\circ $$Both are positive, so both triangles are valid.
Step 4: Find side \(c\) for each triangle.
Use
$$ \frac{a}{\sin A}=\frac{c}{\sin C} $$Since
$$ \frac{7}{\sin 30^\circ}=\frac{7}{0.5}=14 $$Triangle 1:
$$ c_1=14\sin 104.42^\circ\approx 14(0.9683)\approx 13.56 $$Triangle 2:
$$ c_2=14\sin 15.58^\circ\approx 14(0.2685)\approx 3.76 $$Answers:
- Triangle 1: \(B\approx 45.58^\circ\), \(C\approx 104.42^\circ\), \(c\approx 13.56\)
- Triangle 2: \(B\approx 134.42^\circ\), \(C\approx 15.58^\circ\), \(c\approx 3.76\)
Worked Example 4: One triangle only
Given \(A=50^\circ\), \(a=12\), and \(b=9\), solve the triangle.
Step 1: Check the number of possible triangles.
Since \(a=12\) and \(b=9\), we have \(a>b\). For an acute angle \(A\), this means there is one triangle.
Step 2: Find angle \(B\).
$$ \sin B=\frac{b\sin A}{a}=\frac{9\sin 50^\circ}{12} $$ $$ \sin B\approx \frac{9(0.7660)}{12}=0.5745 $$ $$ B_1=\sin^{-1}(0.5745)\approx 35.07^\circ $$The second possible angle would be
$$ B_2=180^\circ-35.07^\circ=144.93^\circ $$But then
$$ A+B_2=50^\circ+144.93^\circ=194.93^\circ $$This is greater than \(180^\circ\), so the second angle is not possible.
Step 3: Find angle \(C\).
$$ C=180^\circ-50^\circ-35.07^\circ=94.93^\circ $$Step 4: Find side \(c\).
$$ \frac{12}{\sin 50^\circ}=\frac{c}{\sin 94.93^\circ} $$ $$ c=12\cdot\frac{\sin 94.93^\circ}{\sin 50^\circ} $$ $$ c\approx 12\cdot\frac{0.9963}{0.7660}\approx 15.61 $$Answer: One triangle exists, with \(B\approx 35.07^\circ\), \(C\approx 94.93^\circ\), and \(c\approx 15.61\).
8. Important notes about obtuse given angles
If the given angle \(A\) is obtuse, the ambiguous case becomes easier to judge.
- If \(A\) is obtuse, then side \(a\) must be the longest side.
- So if \(a\le b\), then no triangle is possible.
- If \(a>b\), then exactly one triangle is possible.
This makes sense because the side opposite the largest angle must be the longest side.
9. Common mistakes to avoid
- Mismatching sides and angles. Always pair \(a\) with \(A\), \(b\) with \(B\), and \(c\) with \(C\).
- Forgetting the second angle. If you use inverse sine, always check whether \(180^\circ-\theta\) also works.
- Not checking the angle sum. A second triangle is only valid if all three angles can still add to \(180^\circ\).
- Rounding too early. Keep several decimal places until the final answer.
- Using the Law of Sines when side-angle pairs are not known. Make sure you have at least one known side and its opposite angle.
10. A step-by-step strategy for SSA problems
- Identify the known angle and its opposite side.
- Use the Law of Sines to compute the unknown sine value.
- If the sine value is greater than 1, no triangle exists.
- Find the first possible angle using inverse sine.
- Find the second possible angle using \(180^\circ-\theta\).
- Check whether each option gives a valid triangle angle sum.
- For each valid triangle, find the remaining angle and side(s).
11. Why this matters in applications
In applications of trigonometry, you may use the Law of Sines to model situations involving distances, directions, and non-right triangles. For example, surveyors, navigators, and engineers often solve oblique triangles when direct measurement is difficult.
The ambiguous case matters because a set of measurements might describe more than one possible shape. If you do not check for both possibilities, you could miss a valid answer or report the wrong one.
Brief Summary
The Law of Sines is used to solve oblique triangles by relating each side to the sine of its opposite angle:
$$ \frac{a}{\sin A}=\frac{b}{\sin B}=\frac{c}{\sin C} $$For ASA and AAS, there is always one triangle. For SSA, the situation can be ambiguous, giving zero, one, or two triangles.
To solve SSA problems correctly, compute the missing sine value, consider both possible angles, and check whether each one creates a valid triangle. Careful checking is the key to handling the ambiguous case successfully.
Put what you read to the test
You've worked through The Law of Sines and the Ambiguous Case. Try answering a few questions to see what stuck — and what might deserve a quick reread before you move on.